Best Magic: The Gathering Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Play Booster Box deal: Below market value at Amazon

BELOW MARKET VALUE: The Magic: The Gathering Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Play Booster Box is $159.99 at Amazon. That’s market value compared to TCGplayer’s price of $173.10.

If you loved the Universe Beyond outings for Marvel’s Spider-Man and Avatar: The Last Air Bender, the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle collection is dropping on March 6, 2026 with an epic artstyle that goes back to the franchise’s gritty comic roots.

The Magic: The Gathering Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Play Booster Box is $159.99 at Amazon, which is $13.11 less than TCGplayer’s price of $173.10. Shockingly, that means Amazon is well below market value. If you pre-order now you won’t get charged until it ships in March 2026, and Amazon’s preorder guarantee means you’ll only be charged the cheapest price it gets listed for between now and the release date.

Every booster has the following inside:

That’s a lot of turtles.

Most valuable Magic: The Gathering Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles cards

Credit: Wizards of the Coast

There’s already presale single card listings for single Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle MTG cards on TCGplayer, which means you can snap up chase cards before they explode. One thing is for sure, it’s going to be a lot cheaper buying these cards now instead of hoping to pull something from a Booster Box.

Here’s the top five most valuable MTG Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles cards you can pre-order right now:

1. Super Shredder #83
   Near Mint Holofoil: $59.99
   Market price: $60
   Most recent sale: $59.99

2. Leonardo, the Balance (Borderless) #1
   Near Mint Holofoil: $44.92
   Market price: $45
   Most recent sale: $45

3. Raphael, the Muscle (Borderless) #4
   Near Mint Holofoil: $44.92
   Market price: $45
   Most recent sale: $45

4. Donatello, the Brains (Borderless) #2
   Near Mint Holofoil: $44.92
   Market price: $45
   Most recent sale: $44.99

5. Michelangelo, the Heart (Borderless) #5
   Near Mint Holofoil: $44.92
   Market price: $45
   Most recent sale: $45